Info
Main/News
FAQ
Contact
Reviews
Date
Filename
Map Name
Misc.
Textures
Demos
Links
 |
The 100b Contest - Part the Third
Download (BSPs)
I believe it was Aardappel who took a cue from a similar mapping contest
held on a doom forum and opened up the first 100 brush contest. Grindspire started this
third incarnation: "The rules are really simple: make a Quake SP map (yes, Quake 1) using
at most 100 brushes and using any textures you wish." After lots of inexplicable wrangling
over who was going to judge the maps that I don't even want to THINK about, xen has sent me
the four maps he received and I'm going to judge them.
participation 4th place award:
100b3
by necros

This map looks like a pile of horse shit. The author said it himself
on QMap, which on one hand makes me not worry about repeating his words but on the other
hand I'm even more infuriated that this garbage got released. What the hell was he thinking?
And why did it take so long to compile if it ISN'T EVEN LIT? I actually ran a Light program
on it to see if it was forgotten somehow and the entire map went fulldark. The screenshot is all you need to see: Shubby trapped in a too-small box, a gang of
fiends, an entire floor plastered with 50% SCALED TEXTURES, etc. The map is kinda floating in a
big box of red sky texture, hinting at a coagula/spacemap concept, but since there's no kill
trigger at the bottom of the sky and you just walk around looking at boring fullbright
walls until you die, I'm more inclined to believe that necros gave up when the map still
wasn't finished and drew the box so it would compile. I can't comment on the gameplay because
I quit well before completing it. I still haven't mentioned the worst
aspect of this map - namely, the filesize. This is the largest map in the pack by a good
600KB and at 2.3MB it no longer deserves the designation of "contest entry" but a more
accurate label such as "act of blatant sabotage."
3rd place:
Fired Ice
By Stargazer

This map froze up Winquake on xen's computer but I couldn't reproduce
the problem. Hopefully neither can you. Here we have a map in a
minimal but appealing style, with worn field stone bricks, brown floors, wood details, etc.
like e2m7 or anything with a similar style. True to that, there is also green slime put to
good use a-la e4m2, especially in one semi-puzzle at the start. The lighting is bland but mostly natural
and definitely sufficient. Combat is alright, reasonably challenging
and escalating. The "cold tower" is a nice idea, as is the area just before the shambler
cave. Ammo supply is a little high. What puzzles me about this map is
the fact that it's surprisingly unpolished. Mistextured walls and misaligned brushes abound.
Door textures are used inappropriately and the lifts are too-small platforms floating in
the air rather than rising from the floor. With more coherent build quality, this map could
have contended much more seriously with the next two.
2nd place:
S4wk
By RPG

"RPG made a natural terrain map with 100 brushes?" This statement, complete
with question mark, was the subject of much discussion on #terrafusion. He did. The map is
100% terrain except for a small and simple brick structure at the end. The idea is really
cool and executed well, although (Ogre Mine flashbacks) all
the areas look exactly the same. It's a water-filled
canyon using a combination of two rock textures (rather ugly dark ones at that) and lots
of sunlight. Monsters are found in large groups that seek to overwhelm the player with
numbers and strategic positioning, and playing through the map is fun if you can ignore the
annoying RPG-ese text messages. The ending is both challenging and hilarious, almost making
up for the text. ;P
1st place:
Dismembered Crates
By distrans

We have a winner. Distrans (who participated in the first two contests
as Palldjon) has passed by the gimmicks of the previous maps and simply focused on creating a
damn good Q1SP level. It uses an impressive number of tricks - large composite ogro/industrial textures,
curves and angles, minimal brush detail on otherwise flat walls - to make the map as detailed as
possible within the restrictions. Aside from the large multi-tiered starting room, there is
also a small interim area and an impressively large and brush-heavy rock area. Fighting is
as good as could be hoped for, on the frantic side. The number of enemies at the very
beginning is considerable but shouldn't be a problem for anyone with cautious tactics or
good evasive skills. The ending is slightly disappointing when the "armored guardian"
guarded by all those monsters turns out to be a lame boss that you don't even need to
fight before exiting, but even this doesn't ruin the experience.
Thanks and congratulations to everyone who participated!
|
|