Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision
Previous revision
tronyn-reviews:arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors [2018/01/22 11:33] negketronyn-reviews:arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors [2018/01/22 14:45] (current) negke
Line 1: Line 1:
-=====Arcane Dimensions + related maps by various authors=====+=====Arcane Dimensions + related maps by various authors (1/4)=====
   * [[/reviews/ad_v1_70final.html|ad_v1_70final.zip - Arcane Dimensions]] by **various authors**   * [[/reviews/ad_v1_70final.html|ad_v1_70final.zip - Arcane Dimensions]] by **various authors**
   * Download: [[/filebase/ad_v1_70final.zip|ad_v1_70final.zip]]   * Download: [[/filebase/ad_v1_70final.zip|ad_v1_70final.zip]]
   * [[/reviews/func_xmasjam2017.html|func_xmasjam2017.zip - Func XMAS Jam 2017]] by **various authors**   * [[/reviews/func_xmasjam2017.html|func_xmasjam2017.zip - Func XMAS Jam 2017]] by **various authors**
   * Download: [[/filebase/func_xmasjam2017.zip|func_xmasjam2017.zip]] + [[/filebase/xmasjam_sock.zip|xmasjam_sock.zip]]   * Download: [[/filebase/func_xmasjam2017.zip|func_xmasjam2017.zip]] + [[/filebase/xmasjam_sock.zip|xmasjam_sock.zip]]
-  * [[/reviews/mjb_horse.html|mjb_horse.zip - A Horse Named Quake]] by [[/reviews/?filtered=Bloughsburgh|Bloughsburgh]]+  * [[/reviews/mjb_horse.html|mjb_horse.zip - A Horse Named Quake]] by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=Bloughsburgh|Bloughsburgh]]
   * Download: [[/filebase/mjb_horse.zip|mjb_horse.zip]]   * Download: [[/filebase/mjb_horse.zip|mjb_horse.zip]]
-   * [[/reviews/ad_fenrir.html|ad_fenrir.zip - Tomb of Fenrir]] by [[/reviews/?filtered=Giftmacher|Giftmacher]] +  * [[/reviews/ad_e3m2.html|ad_e3m2.zip - The Faults Within]] by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=mfx|mfx]] 
-   * [[/reviews/ad_scastle.html|ad_scastle.zip - Nyarlathotep’s Sand Castle]] by [[/reviews/?filtered=sock|sock]]+  * Download: [[/filebase/ad_e3m2.zip|ad_e3m2.zip]] 
 +  * [[/reviews/ad_fenrir.html|ad_fenrir.zip - Tomb of Fenrir]] by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=Giftmacher|Giftmacher]] 
 +   * [[/reviews/ad_scastle.html|ad_scastle.zip - Nyarlathotep’s Sand Castle]] by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=sock|sock]]
   * Download: [[/filebase/ad_scastle.zip|ad_scastle.zip]]   * Download: [[/filebase/ad_scastle.zip|ad_scastle.zip]]
-  * [[/reviews/ad_paradise.html|ad_paradise.zip - Paradise Sickness]] by [[/reviews/?filtered=Redfield|Redfield]]+  * [[/reviews/ad_paradise.html|ad_paradise.zip - Paradise Sickness]] by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=Redfield|Redfield]]
   * Download: [[/filebase/ad_paradise.zip|ad_paradise.zip]]   * Download: [[/filebase/ad_paradise.zip|ad_paradise.zip]]
  
  
-Reviewed and ranked by [[/reviews/?filtered=Tronyn|Dustin 'Tronyn' Geeraert]].+Reviewed and ranked by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=Tronyn|Dustin 'Tronyn' Geeraert]].
  
-[[/tronyn_reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors|Ranks 37-30]] | [[/tronyn_reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_2|Ranks 29-20]] | [[/tronyn_reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_3|Ranks 19-10]] | [[/tronyn_reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_4|Ranks 9-1]]+[[/tronyn-reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors|Ranks 37-31]] | [[/tronyn-reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_2|Ranks 30-21]] | [[/tronyn-reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_3|Ranks 20-11]] | [[/tronyn-reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_4|Ranks 10-1]]
  
  
Line 22: Line 24:
 {{:tronyn-reviews:0ad_1.jpg?direct&300 |}} {{:tronyn-reviews:0ad_1.jpg?direct&300 |}}
  
-__**Arcane Dimensions**__ is a single player and coop Quake mod created by [[http://www.simonoc.com|Simon O’Callaghan]] (aka Sock), a longtime game designer who reconsidered commonly used or well-established Quake design principles. His early design criticism was compared to Martin Luther’s Ninety-Five Theses. Whether it is evolution or revolution, Arcane Dimensions represents the realization of the design vision Sock first outlined a few years ago. It’s great news for the Quake community and the most influential mod since Quoth, and the recent release of the final version represents an interesting opportunity to consider the shifting trends in level design over the last few years.+__**Arcane Dimensions**__ is a single player and coop Quake mod started by [[http://www.simonoc.com|Simon O’Callaghan]] (aka Sock), a longtime game designer who reconsidered commonly used or well-established Quake design principles. His early design criticism was compared to Martin Luther’s Ninety-Five Theses. Whether it is evolution or revolution, Arcane Dimensions represents the realization of the design vision Sock first outlined a few years ago. It’s great news for the Quake community and the most influential mod since Quoth, and the recent release of the final version represents an interesting opportunity to consider the shifting trends in level design over the last few years.
  
 {{ :tronyn-reviews:0ad_2.jpg?direct&300|}} {{ :tronyn-reviews:0ad_2.jpg?direct&300|}}
Line 34: Line 36:
  
  
-__**37. The Grotto by [[/reviews/?filtered=sock|Sock]]**__ +__**37. The Grotto by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=sock|Sock]]**__ 
-    + 
 +{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_sock1.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_sock2.jpg?direct&250}} 
 While this whole list is in some sense comparing apples and oranges, that is             particularly the case with this Christmas jam map. It's definitely amusing/fun, but it's also very short. Not wanting to spoil any surprises I will say that this level is like Sock meets Madfox, which is awesome, but difficult to rate in relation to other maps. While this whole list is in some sense comparing apples and oranges, that is             particularly the case with this Christmas jam map. It's definitely amusing/fun, but it's also very short. Not wanting to spoil any surprises I will say that this level is like Sock meets Madfox, which is awesome, but difficult to rate in relation to other maps.
  
  
  
-__**36. Untitled (xmasjam_naitelveni) by [[/reviews/?filtered=Naitelveni|Naitelveni]]**__+__**36. Untitled (xmasjam_naitelveni) by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=Naitelveni|Naitelveni]]**__
  
 {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_naitelveni.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_naitelveni_2.jpg?direct&250}} {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_naitelveni.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_naitelveni_2.jpg?direct&250}}
Line 48: Line 52:
  
  
-__**35. A Horse Named Quake (mjb_horse) by [[/reviews/?filtered=Bloughsburgh|Bloughsburgh]]**__+__**35. A Horse Named Quake (mjb_horse) by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=Bloughsburgh|Bloughsburgh]]**__
  
  
Line 57: Line 61:
  
  
-__**34. Remains in a Manger (xmasjam_dumptruck) by [[/reviews/?filtered=dumptrick_ds|dumptruck_ds]]**__+__**34. Remains in a Manger (xmasjam_dumptruck) by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=dumptruck_ds|dumptruck_ds]]**__
  
 {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_dumptruck.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_dumptruck_2.jpg?direct&250}} {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_dumptruck.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_dumptruck_2.jpg?direct&250}}
Line 65: Line 69:
  
  
-__**33. To Absent Fiends (xmasjam_5th) by [[/reviews/?filtered=FifthElephant|FifthElephant]]**__+__**33. To Absent Fiends (xmasjam_5th) by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=FifthElephant|FifthElephant]]**__
  
 {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_5th.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_5th_2.jpg?direct&250}} {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_5th.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_5th_2.jpg?direct&250}}
Line 73: Line 77:
  
  
-__**32. The Mire (ad_dm5) by [[/reviews/?filtered=ionous|Ionous]]**__+__**32. The Mire (ad_dm5) by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=ionous|Ionous]]**__
  
 {{:tronyn-reviews:0dm5_1.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0dm5_2.jpg?direct&250}} {{:tronyn-reviews:0dm5_1.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0dm5_2.jpg?direct&250}}
Line 81: Line 85:
  
  
-__**31. Etemenanki (xmasjam_ionous) by [[/reviews/?filtered=ionous|Ionous]]**__+__**31. Etemenanki (xmasjam_ionous) by [[https://www.quaddicted.com/reviews/?filtered=ionous|Ionous]]**__
  
 {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_ionous.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_ionous_2.jpg?direct&250}} {{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_ionous.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_ionous_2.jpg?direct&250}}
Line 88: Line 92:
  
  
- +[[/tronyn-reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_2|next page]]
-__**30. Watt Mutt, Dat Mutt (xmasjam_negke) by [[/reviews/?filtered=negke|Negke]]**__ +
- +
-{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_negke.jpg?direct&250}}{{:tronyn-reviews:0xmas_negke_2.jpg?direct&250}} +
- +
-This dark dungeon incorporate Negke's characteristic style with blocks, lights, and panels of various sizes giving the sense of mysterious but functional architecture. The various sizes of lights reminded me of an optometry test, which turned out to be appropriate as the map features a "skull guardian" who watches your every move. As usual with this author what we have here is an interesting take on id (or perhaps Rogue) tech-dungeon Quake themes. +
- +
- +
- +
-[[/tronyn_reviews/arcane_dimensions_by_various_authors_2|next page]]+