i got confused a few times. then a few more times. not bad for 07.1996 otherwise.

I had an incredibly hard time finding my way to the end of this map. Seems overly complicated navigation wise for a map that call itself Basic Castle. Maybe that was the joke!? =) You can watch me play it here: Basic Castle on The Quake Grave

Started off as good, simple fun. Quickly degenerated into a random wander in search of ... what, exactly? It's impossible to tell what you're meant to find, or how. Very frustrating. I rarely give up on a level once I've started it, but I did with this one.

Oh, meant to say -- the reason I played this is because it's the oldest map in the whole Quaddicted archive.

The oldest quake map on Quaddicted, eh? Well, for the first of the first, it's not too bad. It has some decent combat in it. So why did I rate it two? Because I couldn't figure out what the frarf I was supposed to do! I couldn't find how to finish the map, and I think twenty minutes was enough playtime from me on this one. I actually think that if you have enough people, it might be really, really fun for deathmatch because of all the weird hidden passages. I actually quite like some of the item placement too. I wouldn't recommend you play this on its own though.

..not bad ! A squared castle (but well enough built) with an open area surrounding. definitely my cup of tea..ehm Quake !

Very old and ugly map with horrible lighting. I could not find an exit but I killed most of the enemies. There's honestly some pretty alright combat in there but the map itself is so frustratingly confusing that it's just not worth it. A better name would be "Confusing Castle" as I just can't figure out what to do and, judging from the previous comments as well as ArrrCee's video, nobody else could either. I give it 1/5, highly un-recommended.

As I know some will just have to try the oldest level in the archive, and I had some luck with playing through it, I will explain something critical to beating it. Unfortunately, you will soon find that it is much worse than getting lost.

To reach the end of the level, the door at the bottom of the central building needs to be opened. There are several switches that have to be pressed; one is by jumping through the lava on the floor above that door. The rest are all accessed in sequence from the following location. The platform to the left of the entrance holds a teleporter on the right beam with a zombie in front of it. The teleporter needs to be entered from behind by jumping from the left beam (I actually did this when I first played). This will take the player to a room with blood on the walls, where the quicksave and quickload keys will get plenty of use. Multiple rooms each have a button that needs to be pressed to proceed, with another button leading to a death trap and another dropping the player by the entrance.

Clearly better than those maps rated below it on Quaddicted. This map, at the very least, has a serious attempt to construct a geometric likeness of a castle. It also has plenty of stuff to kill and a kind of puzzle to reach the exit (yea, it has an exit!)

But it has some serious shortcomings. Most importantly, key gameplay elements are not signposted. There are teleporters with no teleporter texture, so you can only find them by sound. There are buttons without button textures, so you only find them by accidentally standing on them. There is lava that you have to jump in. A door that blocks the exit says simply "Pain and sacrifice are the keys", which could be the start of a cool puzzle if it weren't quite so cryptic.

There are also the usual problems with early, roughly made maps: z-fighting, misaligned textures, poor lighting (map looks better on fullbright), etc.

I came close to giving this map 2/5 because I had quite a lot of fun at first. But I ended up being confused by the above issues and having to noclip my way to the exit.

Ignore this comment: I am testing whether Quaddicted's implementation of Markdown needs an backslash to escape a following underscore when within backquotes.

• Here is is with\_underscore
• Here it is without_underscore

I had actually found the trial and error sequence of rooms, mentioned by Dymitry earlier, on my own, but it turned out that the last of the rooms, where you have to choose between three teleporters, the teleporter you're supposed to take wouldn't work properly on my playthrough, taking me back to the very same room with the three teleporters.

I found out that the teleporter worked only if I used the noclip cheat. I'm assuming the teleporter destination was too close to a wall, and would result in the player being teleported outside the map, so the teleporter wouldn't work because of that.

I even tried the map on both Quakespasm and the original Quake over DosBox, but the same behaviour occurred in both platforms. I wonder if the map would work on GLQuake or WinQuake, or something. Anyway, because of the map being broken like this and points brought up by previous commenters, I give the map 1/5.

Two big awards for this map:

-Being the first map ever uploaded to the archive. -Being one of the worst maps ever made for Quake.

It's simply that. This map really looks like "my first map for learning muh map mechanics". Horrible use of lightning, terrible use of textures. Absurd geometry. Everything is bad on this map, even the difficulty and the way to beat it is just insanely hard.

Wow man I almost hate the map :V

Two big awards for this map:

-Being the first map ever uploaded to the archive. -Being one of the worst maps ever made for Quake.

It's simply that. This map really looks like "my first map for learning muh map mechanics". Horrible use of lightning, terrible use of textures. Absurd geometry. Everything is bad on this map, even the difficulty and the way to beat it is just insanely hard.

Wow man I almost hate the map :V