Not sure if it's fair to judge speedmaps by the same standards as regular maps, but anyway:

I was very intrigued by the theme of this map pack, and negke's map pulls it off extremely well, I think. It has a unique setting and very creative narrative (it took me two playthroughs to “get it”; at first I thought I had done something wrong, or that there was some sort of bug in the map). It does look rough around the edges, though – literally, in fact. Perhaps a stationary skybox would have worked better?

Zwiffle's map does not seem to have anything to do with the theme, and sadly, I have to agree with its title (“This map sucks”).

I would REALLY like to see an expanded, polished, non-speedmap version of sm145_negke. Any chance of that happening, negke?

Hmm, I kind of regret having rated this. Should have just left a comment.

sm145negke is really a great, unique little map. And to be fair, sm145zwiffle is ok, given that it is a speedmap. Perhaps a 3 would have been more accurate, all things considered.

Aaaand the underscore strikes again...

Spirit, is there any way of modifying or withdrawing a rating given in a moment of poor judgement?

Thanks, Spirit!

Another great experimental find and I mean negke's contribution. Btw, has anyone figured out where the secret is?

The secret is located to the right side of the volcano, within one of the open topped plants.

finally i found a map isnt dark. i looking long times searching a map like that. trees, beautiful sky and clean water together not a darkness map. unlike every other maps. thank for the negke.

I'm on board with Icant here. I enjoyed Negke's map in a minor way, but didn't get much of Zwiffles. It almost felt like it was randomly generated.