Closed Area by digs was about 4/5 hearts for me. The puzzles on how to get to the next area were quite challenging. At one point I had to noclip though, so I must have missed something.

Infiltration, Penetration, Reception by Drew was amazing! 5/5! The end cave area with the castle part was beautiful, especially considering he was only using Quake + Mispack2 textures! This one reminded me a lot of rogue, specifically The Last Bastion. He really captured the feel of Mission Pack 2. Excellent!

15 Years of Abberation by Text_Fish was intriguing. It took me a minute to figure it out. For its length he did a good job with the gameplay and interesting concept, though I only give it 3/5 hearts.

Happy Birthday Quake! by Trinca was a great little map. Lots of fun with a good style! Though some areas were a bit sparse. All in all a fun 4/5 map.

Tribute to Hunted by ZealousQuakeFan (ZQF) was unique in that it's one of very few maps to use the bones texture in a prominent way. It however was very very repetitive since it is a maze. The low monster count but contrasting lighting and texturing hints did help to make it a more enjoyable maze than I would have expected from such repetitious map. Fun but 3/5.

A good map pack even if only for Drew's jewel of a map.

Agreed with pretty much everything Qmaster said above me.

Here's a screenshot of the maps for those interested -

http://s9.postimg.org/hrv0nlmof/smqx11.jpg

SMQX11_DIGS: I love the really hard puzzles!!

digs' map is fun if you finish it and frustrating if you con't. I noclipped to search for clues a couple of times. I solved the number pannel puzzle but have no idea how. Everything seemed easier in retrospect.