This is much better than ok and the best of Scott McNutt's maps on this site, in my opinion.

A little plain by current standards, but nice-looking and quite large. Combat is varied, which is interesting: at times you are almost completely alone, and then you suddenly find yourself attacked from all sides. This creates tension and feels realistic – but sadly, it is usually achieved by having enemies very obviously teleport in, which feels artificial (to me, at least).

3 plus; recommended.

This is definitely better than average--objectively I'd call it a 4, but I give it a 5 because this is the kind of map I really enjoy. It's an old-school castle map with progression that's mostly linear but doesn't feel linear. The two secrets I found were clever. There are also at least a couple unofficial secrets that aren't too difficult to find and spice things up.

The only drawback is what "Icantthink" mentioned-- a lot of the challenge and suspense come from enemies teleporting in near the player, which gets tedious by the end of the map.