Mundane it might be, but I really enjoyed the straightforward blastfest of sm176_doomer. Sometimes I think we need more maps of this Doom-fest type.

(I've not yet successfully played the other two, as I had to reinstall my computer and Quoth doesn't work properly on the new version.)

doomer's map was straight forward. 3/5 cocerello's map i can't quite figure out (for now). drew's map i really liked. tough, large, dark... maybe a little too dark. i was quite short on ammo in the middle of the map(missed secret?), but i had plenty at the end. 4/5

dBAudio, have you played it on Quoth? If it isn't that, you can watch the speedrun demo i provided in this page to know what to do and where to go.

Time held me green and dying/ Though I sang in my chains like the sea (sm176_drew) is a superb map, that absolutely merits its own release. It's a real shame it's buried in a speedmap pack where very few people are likely to see it. It packs the feel of a whole episode into a single level, beginning with base monsters and weapons and progressing through lava pits and big subterranean castle to a satisfying conclusion deep below the earth. Highly recommended.

(As far as I can make out, Drew has never made a full release of any of his maps -- everything he's done has been in speedmap packs. But this is not a speedmap.)

Finally, Calm (sm176_calm) has some nice ideas, but is just too frustrating. Having cleared the second island and been send back to the first, I gave up and noclipped; even then, I couldn't find the way to progress. A disappointing end to an enjoyable pack.